The Impact of the CoVid-19 Pandemic upon the Contracts in Progress. Special View upon the Unforeseeability in the Regulation of the Romanian Civil Code
Keywords:
Romanian Civil Code, unforeseeability, the conditions of unforeseeability, the effects of unforeseeability, CoVid-19 pandemic, the limitation of the binding force of the contractAbstract
In the context of the deep economic changes generated by the SARS-CoV-2 pandemic, the debates regarding the institution of unforeseeability have returned. It is a fact that the measures ordered by the authorities to limit the spread of the pandemic affect the possibility of fulfilling contractual obligations, so that the contracting parties are put in a position to analyze the contractual mechanisms available to remedy the situation. The Romanian legal system considers the unforeseeability as an exception from the principle of the binding force of the contract, being expressly stated by the current Civil Code. It is applicable, as a rule, for the synallagmatic, onerous, commutative and with successive or continuous execution contracts. This exception may be invoked if the execution of the contract has become excessively onerous for one of the parties, because of the occurrence of certain events independent of the will of the parties and which caused an imbalance between their services, impossible to foresee at the time of concluding the act. Invoking the unforeseen allows the contract to be renegotiated. If the parties do not reach an agreement, at the request of one of them, the court may adjust or order the cessation of the contract. Starting from the fact that there are multiple situations in which the spread of the CoVid-19 has determined a contractual imbalance, which needs to be remedied, as well as the fact that practically there is still a confusion between the application of the unforeseeability and the situations in which the major force occurs as an exonerating cause of liability, the objective of the current article is to analyze the concept of unforeseeability and the legal regime applicable to it, by emphasizing the conditions which need to be met in order to be in the presence of this exception from the principle of the binding force of the contract.
References
Anton G., Teoria impreviziunii în dreptul românesc şi dreptul comparat, “Law Magazine” 2000, No 7.
Bojică C., Dunca R., Coronavirus și contractele comerciale, available online at https://www.universuljuridic.ro/coronavirus-si-contractele-comerciale/.
Boroi G., Anghelescu C.A., Curs de drept civil. Partea generală, 2nd Edition, Hamangiu Publ.-house, Bucharest 2012.
Chelaru E., Duminică R., Partea generală a dreptului civil, University of Pitești Press, Pitești 2016.
Chelaru E., Teoria generală a dreptului civil, C.H. Beck Publ.-house, Bucharest 2014.
Chelaru E., Forţa obligatorie a contractului, teoria impreviziunii şi competenţa în materie a instanţelor judecătoreşti, “Law Magazine” 2003, No 9.
Cercel S., Munteanu C. (coord.), Fișe de drept civil. Partea generală, Universul Juridic Publ.-house, Bucharest 2018.
de Gaudin de Lagrange E., L’intervention du juge dans le contrat, thèse, Paris 1935.
Ghestin J., Jamin C., Billjau M., Traité de droit civil: Les effets du contrat, LGDJ, Paris 2001.
Ghestin J., Traite de droit civil. La formation du contrat, LGDJ, Paris 1993.
Philippe D.M., Changement des circonstances et bouleversement dès l’économie contractuelle, Bruxelles 1986.
Pivniceru M.M., Efectele juridice ale contractelor aleatorii, Hamangiu Publ.-house, Bucharest 2009.
Pop L., Popa I.-F., Vidu S.I., Tratat elementar de drept civil. Obligațiile conform noului Cod civil, Universul Juridic Publ.-house, Bucharest 2012.
Sandar V., Configurația impreviziunii în noul Cod civil. Considerații cu privire la clauzele de hardship, “Romanian Business Law Magazine” 2013, No 10.
Șeulean C., D. Popa, Impreviziunea. Considerații teoretice. Aspecte practice, available online at https://ww.universuljuridic.ro/impreviziunea-consideratii-teoretice-aspecte-practice/.
Starck B., Droit civil. Obligations. Contrats, 2nd Volume, Litec Publ.-house, Paris 1993.
Stătescu C., Bîrsan C., Teoria generală a obligaţiilor, All Beck Publ.-house, Bucharest 2002.
Uluitu A.G. in Fl.A. Baias, E. Chelaru, R. Constantinovici, I. Macovei, Noul Cod Civil – Comentariu pe articole, C. H. Beck Publ.-house, Bucharest 2012.
Zamșa Cristina in Fl.A. Baias, E. Chelaru, R. Constantinovici, I. Macovei (coord.), Noul Cod Civil – Comentariu pe articole, C. H. Beck Publ.-house, Bucharest 2012.
Zamşa C.E., Teoria impreviziunii. Studiu de doctrină şi jurisprudenţă, Hamangiu Publ.-house, Bucharest 2006.
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
Copyright (c) 2021 Ramona Duminică
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
